This woman went to hospital with back pain and died. Now her family wants answers from Niagara Health

This New Year’s Eve, Francine Shimizu marked three weeks since the lack of her daughter. 

On Dec. 9, Heather Winterstein went alone to the emergency department at St. Catharines Basic Hospital in Ontario for a critical backache, her circle of relatives says. Earlier that week, she had fallen down some stairs at her father’s house the place she have been living and was in a lot of ache, her mom informed CBC.

not up to 48 hours later, the 24-year-vintage died. 

Her family says Heather was once to begin with despatched home with Tylenol but lower back to health facility the following day, best to break down in the ready room.  

members of the family say they have been told by means of the local public health unit that she had died from a Strep A blood an infection. They were given the inside track after they had been referred to as for Strep A touch tracing after her demise.

Lately, the family has many questions surrounding her dying on Dec. 10, together with whether Heather gained the right care, and whether her drug use or Indigenous historical past may have played a role in her treatment in some way. 

“She used to be so loving, she was once so giving,” Shimizu said, including that her daughter was working to complete her high school degree and hoped to review nursing, as her mother did.  “She did not need to be treated like that.”

Family questions linger

From their respective houses, Shimizu and Mark Winterstein, Heather’s father, are now in search of solutions as they plan a funeral and celebration of life later this month. 

“i don’t want somebody else’s kid in search of help… being on my own. God… it just kills me. It simply kills me to grasp that she was once struggling,” Shimizu stated.

This woman went to hospital with back pain and died. Now her family wants answers from Niagara Health

Winterstein, pictured round Christmas 2018, used to be ‘so loving, she was once so giving,’ says her mom, Francine Shimizu. (Submitted by way of Rosemary Ripper)

Neither the coroner nor Niagara Heath used to be in a position to confirm the cause of Heather’s death to CBC News, and the standards that will have performed a task best as much as it remain unknown. Alternatively, Niagara Health said “an interior high quality care evaluate is underway to totally remember the patient’s experience, and the circle of relatives shall be curious about this procedure.”

In a press release to CBC, Lynn Guerriero, Niagara Health president and chief government officer, said she used to be “deeply ” by way of the troubles raised in regards to the loss of life.

She also stated she has spoken to Heather’s circle of relatives and may talk to Indigenous leaders in the neighborhood.

“i will be able to also be suggesting that this unbiased evaluate look extra widely on the well being-care studies of Indigenous sufferers and their concerns,” said Guerriero. 

Niagara Health stated it’s additionally “fully co-working” with an investigation conducted by the Ontario coroner’s administrative center.  

2 days of ache and confusion 

From his house in St. Catharines, Heather’s father Mark recalled the painful days prior to his daughter died. 

He told CBC News that the evening she got here home with Tylenol after the first health center discuss with, he did his easiest to assist her get comfortable so she could get a few sleep.

Whilst she aroused from sleep the following morning, he recalled, Heather instructed him that she used to be nonetheless in excruciating ache and asked him to call an ambulance.

Mark stated the paramedics who arrived informed Heather that they would take her to the urgent care centre in Citadel Erie, but she could spend up to 8 hours within the ready room.

“It did not look like they desired to take her, but i assume they also concept her pain was from a fall,” Mark stated. “they just thought she needed relax.”

He stated that in the long run, he relied on the judgment of the paramedics. 

When Mark later referred to as the sanatorium in Citadel Erie to test in, he used to be instructed the 24-year-old was once if truth be told at St. Catharines Common. Mark believes Heather most likely insisted the paramedics take her to the emergency division there.

He mentioned the person at the telephone told him he had to come to the medical institution very quickly, however would not tell him why. 

As Mark and his fiancé drove to the sanatorium on Dec. 10, he questioned what could be flawed.

“Again accidents now and again can be lifelong and… he thought, ‘That’s GOOD ENOUGH — we’ll simply find out what it’s and we’ll handle it,'” Mark recalled.

Upon his arrival that evening, Mark said, he learned from docs that his daughter had died. 

Niagara Emergency Clinical Services And Products later confirmed to CBC that they answered to a 911 demand Heather on Dec. 10 and they “have devoted to totally consider the events that transpired leading to the loss of life of Ms. Winterstein,” together with collaborating within the 3rd-birthday party evaluation, however could not comment on the case additional.  

Her final moments

Shimizu, who stated she used to be indexed as her daughter’s emergency contact, was referred to as to the hospital at EIGHT:30 p.m. on Dec. 10, she says. 

She stated she arrived to be told that clinical group of workers have been seeking to resuscitate Heather and walked in as they were doing chest compressions on her non-responsive daughter. Her mother mentioned she used to be stated dead 15 minutes later.

Shimizu mentioned Heather have been there for some time already, and he or she now wonders why she wasn’t contacted via the health center sooner. 

This woman went to hospital with back pain and died. Now her family wants answers from Niagara Health

a picture shared on snapchat of Winterstein, proper, and her mom, Francine Shimizu, from 2020. (Submitted by Francine Shimizu)

Shimizu, who is a registered nurse and works in long-term care, mentioned a better level of care should have been supplied for her daughter.

“They Are supposed to be the experts,” she said.

Mark has similar concerns.

“As quickly as any person comes during the hospital door, it is a secure assumption that they’re there for a reason.”

Shimizu cited that police had been called to the health center and interviewed her, although she is not sure why.

Niagara Regional Police Provider showed to CBC that officers were notified of the demise of a 24-year-old girl on the health center on Dec. 10. However, “at this time the reason behind dying has not been determined to be criminal in nature.”

Police mentioned they couldn’t say extra due to privateness considerations.

Unknown elements

Shimizu defined her daughter as a caring person who had a keenness for animals and appreciated to draw. 

Shimizu stated Heather had gotten in with the incorrect crowd as a young person, and had battled despair and drug use, but was getting assist via counselling and remedy at an area methadone health center.

Then Again, she now asks if her drug use might need motivated how she used to be cared for. 

“one of the primary issues that the doctor mentioned to me used to be that they spotted track marks on my daughter,” Shimizu said, relating to marks that can point out intravenous drug use. That in advance reference her.

“We were engaged on her. We had been attempting to assist her with her habit and we simply wanted extra time.” 

Shimizu also wonders if her daughter’s Indigenous heritage could had been a factor in her care. 

A Primary Nations guy died day after leaving Ontario health center with headache pills. Now his family wants answersHealth care machine used to be designed to subject Indigenous people to systemic racism: Hajdu

“They Are Going To now not have identified her as that, but the truth of the problem is that she is Indigenous,” Shimizu stated.

While Winterstein has Indigenous background — her mom says Shimizu and her sister had been followed once they have been young and reconnected with circle of relatives on Six Countries of the Grand River within the nineteen nineties — it is unclear whether or now not the health facility personnel knew that.

CBC has not reviewed any documents associated with the family’s historical past.

Wendy Sturgeon, executive director of the Niagara Chapter of Local Women, informed CBC that throughout the local Indigenous group, she knew of Shimizu and her sister Jill, who works in Indigenous child welfare. 

Speaking extensively, Sturgeon pointed to a historical past of racism that impacts the way in which Indigenous folks across Canada are treated in well being care. 

On The Other Hand, she mentioned Niagara Health has spent the prior few years running closely with the native Indigenous Health Community to glue health-care suppliers with Indigenous cultural safety coaching. 

She advised CBC she has been aware of the case involving Heather, and bearing in mind up to date deaths of Indigenous people in Ontario and Quebec related to well being care, she’ll be looking at what happens next.

“i was relatively stunned,” Sturgeon said, referring to Heather’s story. “This Indigenous neighborhood has expended so much of energy and so much of time to work with the entire health-care suppliers to the best of our skill.”

Heather’s aunt, Jill, believes the health-care machine failed her niece. 

“Heather goes with a strep an infection and he or she’s useless. That makes no feel,” she mentioned. “it’s not fair to my sister and Heather’s father. My heart just breaks for them.”

Leave a comment