There’s a big plan to slow erosion in the Magdalen Islands. But will it work?

An $11.6-million plan to gradual the erosion of a prone part of sea coast in Quebec’s Magdalen Islands will involve dumping thousands of tonnes of gravel on a seashore that may be being unexpectedly eaten away through the tumultuous waters of the Gulf of St. Lawrence.

The municipality’s director of engineering, Jean Hubert, said the mission will do greater than just offer protection to buildings and infrastructure like a cinema and the region’s only clinic in Cap-aux-Meules.

“It additionally creates a base that may be utilized by other folks as soon as the seashore softens. it’ll make the ocean available,” he said.

however the concept of the usage of gravel to protect a beach from the round-the-clock onslaught of tidal waters and the upcoming risk of local weather change makes little sense to a coastal erosion and seashore control knowledgeable who has spent a lot of his career within the nearby province of Prince Edward Island.

“To be frank, the one factor that i know of in this situation that can provide 40 to 50 years durability is armour stone revetment — a wall manufactured from huge armour stone,” mentioned Robin Davidson-Arnott, professor emeritus within the department of geography, setting and geomatics on the College of Guelph.

The Ones stones are very dear and might have to be introduced in through barge, he explained, however the wall could last more than the sloping gravel pile officials plan to put in this coming fall.

Time to take into consideration retreat, knowledgeable says

Davidson-Arnott has no longer noticed the research proving the plan in the Magdalen Islands will work, but he suspects it won’t final greater than 5 years as waves will wash it away, doubtlessly doing more injury because the abrasive sediment is carried down the sea coast through the water.

“they say there may be a 40-12 months lifespan by which they’ll need to do nothing. if you are going to say that, you really must have superb information and excellent simulations to justify that,” he said.

“Anything is feasible, however given what they’re putting in place there, i’d wish to be very, very reassured that they’ve performed their homework in this, and frankly, I just don’t believe it.”

The region’s only medical institution is threatened by means of coastal erosion, motivating the municipality, in partnership with the federal and provincial governments, to invest in protecting the coast. (Isabelle Larose/Radio-Canada)

Davidson-Arnott stated, given the results of local weather amendment and the level of the erosion so that they can come, it is time to suppose extra approximately chickening out than looking to struggle again the tough waves.

The erosion of the archipelago’s brittle cliff-lined coast is a priority all through much of the Maggies, however six explicit areas have been focused via a special committee that may be working to offer protection to historical sites, buildings and municipal infrastructure.

Those six areas will obtain priority provincial monetary help to build protective structures, including L. A. Grave and Cap-aux-Meules.

857 metres of sea coast coated in gravel

Paintings at the scenic but eroding crimson sandstone cliffs of Cap-aux-Meules, thought to be the downtown core of the islands, will include backfilling a element of seashore that stretches 857 metres.

The gravel mix will succeed in an elevation of approximately four metres above sea level, or about two times as tall as basketball superstar Michael Jordan. 

A Total of 67,000 cubic metres of combination can be used, together with 20,000 in an instant from the Magdalen Islands. The municipality is overlaying about $1 million, and the remaining is being covered by the provincial and federal governments. 

There's a big plan to slow erosion in the Magdalen Islands. But will it work?

Erosion of the coastline has broken a popular motorcycle trail within the Magdalen Islands. (Radio-Canada)

The project is predicted to take about 10 weeks to complete — a section was already filled in at the back of the Cinema Cyrco. A Call for tenders can be made subsequent month.

Hubert said there are individuals who query the venture’s viability, nevertheless it is absolutely supported by means of the province’s Ministry of Public Safety.

“Many People may doubt the solutions put forward, but the various protection scenarios have been evaluated and tested with hydro-sedimentary simulations,” he stated.

As beaches reduce, local weather change a constant danger to residents of the Magdalen Islands

Eroding at rate of half metre in keeping with 12 months

The gravel mixture will have a diameter of 40 millimetres. Other measures are being taken along different coasts in the Magdalen islands, however the aggregates used to backfill along Cap-aux-Meules will probably be particularly coarse, as a result of it’s battered laborious by means of storms, and desires further protection, stated Hubert.

“it’s therefore now not high-quality sand as we know at the stunning seashores of the Magdalen Islands,” Hubert stated. “Plus, this same subject material already exists within the sector it can be safe and it has been provide for more than FORTY years.”

Hubert said this measure can be less visible by means of boaters on the water than different options officials considered. He said it is going to have compatibility higher with the panorama.

Magdalen Islands officials asking for $EIGHTY million from the province to combat coastal erosion

Researchers from Université du Québec à Rimouski were tracking erosion on the islands for many years. Due To The Fact That 2005, the rate of abrasion has speeded up, amounting to approximately 46 centimetres — or half a metre — consistent with 12 months.

Once backfilled, Hubert mentioned the aggregates will create a natural slope on which the waves can run aground in preference to reaching the buildings.

“The fill reacts very, rather well to the onslaught of waves and behaves as expected,” he stated.

Leave a comment